Target Costume Apology Needed to Aim at More Detail
Last week, a backlash caused Target to pull a racist Halloween costume and apologize. This isn’t the first political turmoil the U.S. retail giant has experienced, and the criticism continues. Target’s perfunctory apology drives home that crisis mea culpas that avoid detail aren’t going to cut it anymore.
Target announced it was pulling the product on Aug. 24. The Kids’ Circus Glow Clown Halloween Costume Bodysuit is a black and orange outfit with miniature hat, black gloves and a mesh mask featuring large lips and teeth. Target ran a promotional photo of a Black child modeling the costume and resembling a Jim Crow–era minstrel character. Not good.
Here’s Target’s full apology on X:
“An apology from us: We pulled an offensive Halloween costume that should never have been part of our assortment. It is no longer for sale. As a company, we got this wrong, and we are deeply sorry. We know this is especially hurtful for our Black guests, team members and partners. Removing the costume is an important first step, and the company is looking closely at how this happened and what needs to change to ensure this won’t happen again.”
Provide Detail
While this is a typical apology for a situation like this, the approach may not be seen (and is not being seen) as enough. While it’s not unusual for retailers to blunder, companies may need to provide more detail on how such a mistake occurred. Going by comments we’ve seen on social media, the public is clamoring for further explanation. Target hasn’t provided it. Even if the information isn’t available for the initial statement, it could be included in the follow-up.
To make matters worse, the situation apparently did “happen again” — already! Target pulled a Halloween costume of a World War II German soldier’s uniform just this week, according to Newsweek.
Another problem here is that Target has had bad experiences like this in the past. As we like to say, it doesn’t have a positive balance in the Credibility Bank. In 2023 it suffered a backlash when it removed some LGBTQ-themed merchandise. In January 2025, under pressure from the Trump Administration, it pulled back on its diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives, which led to boycotts. Commenters have pondered whether this crisis would have happened had that not been so.
Fox 9 KMSP in Minneapolis, where Target is based, reported that civil-rights activists from National Target Boycott held a protest over the clown costume at the company’s headquarters building.
Shares Fell
This crisis came just as the company’s sales have been improving, the business press reported. Target shares fell as much as 5 percent the day after the apology, according to Reuters. “Target keeps showing us who they are,” a Minneapolis entrepreneur who protested the company’s dismantling of its DEI initiatives told Reuters about the clown costume.
Reuters got ahold of an internal email in which Chief Merchandising Officer Cara Sylvester told staff the company would “learn from this and do better.” We hope it does. That includes providing more information about the processes that led to this catastrophe.
Photo Credit: Target
Sign up for our free weekly newsletter on crisis communications. Each week we highlight a crisis story in the news or a survey or study with an eye toward the type of best practices and strategies you can put to work each day. Click here to subscribe.